“Propaganda and policemen, prisons and schools, traditional values and traditional morality all serve to reinforce the power of the few and to convince or coerce the many into acceptance of a brutal, degrading and irrational system.”
- Maurice Brinton, “Authoritarian Conditioning, Sexual Repression, and the Irrational in Politics“
We Weren’t “Born This Way”:
A Critique of “Born This Way” by Lady GaGa
by Liam O’Ceallaigh
Last Sunday (13 February 2011) at the 2011 Grammy Awards, Lady GaGa (Stefani Germanotta) began promoting her new album and single Born This Way. Early Thursday morning I wrote a short article “You Weren’t “Born This Way”” critiquing the song and its message, as well as how Lady GaGa arrived at the Grammys (i.e. carried in an egg by horned slaves/servants).
My criticisms were straightforward: (1) rather than being “born this way”, our differences are largely the result of socialisation and choice, and (2) how it is unacceptable for someone who claims to support social justice to arrive at the awards carried by horned slaves/servants.
The article has been passed around a bunch and I’ve received a lot of interesting feedback which has prompted me to pen this followup piece. Hopefully this answers or clarifies some of the questions, concerns, and criticisms people have raised. If after reading this piece you have other comments that weren’t answered or addressed, then please, by all means, e-mail me (butterflywalking (at) gmail (dot) com) or write a comment below.

Hate capitalist alienation and consumerism not those who manage to find love despite it!
For some Valentine’s Day reading check out Alexandra Kollantai’s great pieces The Love of Worker Bees (available through Amazon.com), Red Love (online), and A Great Love (online). Alexandra Kollantai was a member of the Bolshevik Party during the Russian Revolution and wrote extensively on socialism, democracy, and women’s rights and power. Another great reading is Marxist psychoanalyst and social theorist Erich Fromm’s The Art of Loving (online for educational purposes).
If you want a slightly longer (though absolutely excellent and beautifully written!) book, I can’t possibly recommend Myths of Male Dominance: Collected Articles on Women Cross-Culturally by Marxist anthropologist Eleanor Burke Leacock strongly enough. Not widely available since its publishing in 1981, it was recently republished by U.S. socialist publisher Haymarket Books.
From 26 June 2009

.
“Fill your desire for something long, juicy…”
Burger King has really outdone themselves this time. The print advertisement for their new “Super Seven Incher” sandwich features an wide-eyed, blonde-haired, pale-skin, red lip-sticked, blushing woman with her mouth open, about to have Burger King’s Super Seven Incher put in her mouth. The text below? “It’ll Blow Your Mind Away”. Apparently subtlety is lost on them. But perhaps we can learn from this. Countless ads verge on being this explicit, but are masked in “subtlety” which allows the silence of critique. These ads on the other hand, leave no room for dispute.
This ad could be used as an incredibly powerful teaching tool when discussing gender equality with people convinced that women’s oppression is “over”. It’s become increasingly clear, from the assassination of Dr. George Tiller (the women’s healthcare provider in Wichita, Kansas), to the rampage at the U.S. Holocaust Museum, to the murder of a nine year-old Latina girl and her father by Minutemen terrorists, to the recent post-election surge in gun purchases, that the seeds of a very strong far-right-wing revival are underway. In its sights: gains made around women’s rights, rights and services for oppressed people, especially people of color, immigrants, and working people, and consciousness shifts around LGBT rights.
The military’s homophobic “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” policy is on its deathbed while a bipartisan clique of racist, xenophobic, white supremacist bigots in the U.S. Senate have killed the DREAM Act which would provide a pathway to citizenship for many immigrants living in the U.S. How should revolutionaries understand these contradictions? Below are some of my initial thoughts.
I also highly recommend my comrade Michael Strom’s article for the Organization for a Free Society “On Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell, and Supporting Our Troops“, which was written around when I wrote the text below.
Poor taste or complete ignorance?
Candy Magazine is put out by Luis Venegas – “born in Vitoria, Spain, on 13th March 1979″ and “based between Madrid and Barcelona.”
James Franco is an actor. Francisco Franco was the fascist dictator of Spain who crushed the Spanish revolutionaries, installed a fascist dictatorship with himself at the helm, murdered and tortured tens of thousands, forced hundreds of thousands of people into exile, and aided Hitler’s Nazi regime.
Be sure to check out this new piece from the Organization for a Free Society (OFS) written by Angi Becker Stevens and Alex Upham. Its called “Critique of Pure Relationships: On Consent and Compulsory Monogamy“.
Sign up for Updates!
Tags
Afghanistan Antonio Gramsci Barack Obama Capitalism Christianity Class Democracy Egypt Gender Germany Imperialism Iran Ireland Jesus Karl Marx Lenin LGBT LGBTI Libya Links Love Martin Luther King Jr Marxism Materialism Music Palestine Propaganda Quotes Race Racism Religion Repression Resistance Revolution Sexism Sexuality Socialism Solidarity State Terrorism Unions Utopianism Video Vision WarLinks
- 3arabawy
- A Better World is Probable
- A Marxist History of the World – Neil Faulkner (Counterfire)
- Black Agenda Report
- Bradley Manning Support Network
- Carlos Latuff
- Ceasefire Magazine
- Chomsky.info
- Coalition of Immokalee Workers
- David Harvey
- Democracy Now!
- Dollars and Sense
- Feminist Frequency
- Fire in the Mountains
- Glenn Greenwald
- Goddard College
- Haymarket Books
- ill Doctrine
- International Socialism (journal)
- International Socialist Organization (Aotearoa / New Zealand)
- International Socialist Organization (U.S.)
- International Socialist Organization (Zimbabwe)
- International Socialist Review
- International Socialists (Pakistan)
- International Viewpoint
- Iraq Veterans Against the War
- Jacobin Magazine
- John Cronan Jr.
- John Molyneux
- Kevin Gosztola (OpEdNews)
- Kevin Gosztola (The DIssenter)
- Left Business Observer
- Left Turn
- Lenin's Tomb
- Liberty Tree
- Martín Espada
- Marxists Internet Archive
- Michael Albert
- Monthly Review
- MR Zine
- News from the Gutter
- Organization for a Free Society
- Organizing Upgrade
- Partido Socialista Unido de Venezuela / United Socialist Party of Venezuela, PSUV
- Pop Culture Pirate
- Praxis Makes Perfect
- Public Eye
- Rebellious Pixels
- Red Pepper
- Revolutionary Socialists (Egypt)
- Roland Boer
- Sherry Talks Back
- Slim Lopez
- Socialism Conference
- Socialist Alternative (AU)
- Socialist Review
- Socialist Worker
- Socialist Worker UK
- Socialist Workers Party (Ireland)
- Socialist Workers Party (U.K.)
- Solidarity Webzine
- The Real News Network
- Venezuela Analysis
- War Times / Tiempo de Guerras
- We Are Many
- WikiLeaks
- Z Magazine
- ZNet
The Working Class As Vanguard Fighter for Democracy by V. I. Lenin
“…the Social-Democrat [Socialist]’s ideal should not be the trade union secretary, but the tribune of the people, who is able to react to every manifestation of tyranny and oppression, no matter where it appears, no matter what stratum or class of the people it affects; who is able to generalise all these manifestations and produce a single picture of police violence and capitalist exploitation; who is able to take advantage of every event, however small, in order to set forth before all his socialist convictions and his democratic demands, in order to clarify for all and everyone the world-historic significance of the struggle for the emancipation of the proletariat”. - “Trade-Unionist Politics and Social-Democratic[Socialist] Politics: The Working Class As Vanguard Fighter for Democracy” in What Is To Be Done?: Burning Questions of Our Movement by V. I. Lenin
“Like” Us On Facebook
Click HERE to visit our Facebook page. Recent Posts
- Healthcare is a human right, not a mandate to buy private services
- Lukács: ‘concrete analysis is not the opposite of ‘pure’ theory’
- Uniting the Front – Division and Unity on the Left
- Links for 14 March 2012
- Links for 11 March 2012
- Links for 10 March 2012
- Links for 9 March 2012
- A Green Party mayor cracks down
- Why I’m a Marxist (part one)
- Four classics by Lenin
- Chomsky: ‘If the Nuremberg Laws were applied to U.S. presidents’
- Rosa Luxemburg “the mass strike is not artificially ‘made’, not ‘decided’ at random”
- Hitler, Catholics, and birth control
- Tony Kushner: “The dreams of the Left are always beautiful”
- Look here! This is capitalist ‘peace’!
Follow Me On Twitter
Error: Twitter did not respond. Please wait a few minutes and refresh this page.
Monthly Archive
- March 2012 (10)
- February 2012 (7)
- January 2012 (20)
- December 2011 (16)
- November 2011 (10)
- October 2011 (3)
- August 2011 (16)
- July 2011 (12)
- June 2011 (4)
- May 2011 (18)
- April 2011 (9)
- March 2011 (57)
- February 2011 (28)
- January 2011 (34)
- December 2010 (49)




































